Last time I was there the service was the issue, the property was nice enough. The problem with that property is there is not a lot of other options in the area for going out for food/drink. I have noticed this is not isolated to the Frenchman's Reef, seems to be systemic in the islands. If you want a place that you can stay in the property for everything, perhaps Aruba would be better. If you get out and explore the island(s) Frenchman's Reef is a good option. Lots of things to do within a short taxi drive or boat ride
I would say stay away from the property in St. Kitts, I was there not long ago and the service was some of the worst I've had in any Marriott.
More USVI/BVI Threads