Just returned from a 3 night stay and could not have had a better mini-vacation! When we checked in they acknowledged my MR status (Maya) and they upgraded us to a magnificent water & Statue of Liberty view room complete with telescope. When they found out it was my birthday they sent up complimentary champagne! The furnishings were tasteful and very comfortable. All of the staff were extremely attentive and friendly.
My one complaint is that there was no coffee machine in the room (although it was available in the lobby early in the morning). I really like/need a wake up cup and don't like to either have to get dressed to go down to get it or pay $12 for a room service pot.
Concierge Lounge access is not offered to MR guests, but our package included breakfast and the dining room breakfast was very good. Complimentary water, wi-fi, local calls are given.
The Battery Park City location was great for walking to the World Trade Center Memorial, Financial Center, several excellent museums, fantastic restaurants, Tribeca and the South Street Seaport. Dinner service in the restaurant was great as was the food. We even lucked out it being "Restaurant Week" with discounted prix-fixe menus
When we had a problem with oneof our room keys not working and having to have it reprogrammed several times, "for our inconvenience" Linda from Security offered us a complimentary breakfast or lunch.